Virtue Has No Creed: A Defense of Christian Philosophers

I have just read a selection of Christian ethics. It was, in fact, very good. I’m no expert on Christian philosophy, but it seemed just as rigorous as secular philosophy.

Don’t let politics get in the way. If you have bad experiences with a church, don’t let that get in the way, either.

There’s already enough division and divisiveness in the world. Don’t think, if you are a philosopher, that one cannot be both an excellent Christian and an excellent philosopher. Some of the most edifying, intellectual work I’ve read has been by Christian philosophers.

I know there are people who are half-wonked. They fail to embody the virtues.

But that’s not everyone. And, moreover, even if it was everyone, it doesn’t conceptually follow.

Even beyond that, there are vicious people all over the place, not just within the Christian religion. Vice, it seems, has no creed. I doubt virtue does, either.

Beauty Way: Navajo Virtue Ethics

Without appropriating, I’d like to incorporate the Navajo prayer Beauty Way into contemporary virtue ethics. If you’re unfamiliar with this prayer, it goes like this:

Walking in Beauty
(A prayer from the Navajo Nation)


Today I will walk out, today everything unnecessary will leave me, I will be as I was before, I will have a cool breeze over my body. I will have a light body, I will be forever happy, nothing will hinder me. 


I walk with Beauty below me.
I walk with Beauty above me.
I walk with Beauty all around me.
My words will be Beautiful.

In Beauty, all day long, may I walk.
Through the returning seasons, may I walk.
On the trail marked with pollen, may I walk. 

With dew about my feet, may I walk.

With Beauty before me, may I walk.
With Beauty behind me, may I walk.
With Beauty below me, may I walk.
With Beauty above me, may I walk.
With Beauty all around me, may I walk.

In old age wandering a trail of Beauty,
lively, may I walk.
In old age wandering a trail of Beauty,
living again, may I walk. 

It is finished in Beauty.
It is finished in Beauty.
Aho.

It may be easy to see how this prayer–even as a prayer itself–fits into virtue ethics. As a prayer, poem or song, it is a mental action performed; a ritual or tradition. As such, the aim is to cultivate virtues–even, perhaps, the ones alluded to in the prayer.

As a selection of virtue ethics, it sits alongside Christian virtue ethics and Stoic ethics, particularly since it aims to shed unnecessary things, as the Stoics wish the shed “the passions.” Think about it: Everything unnecessary will leave and one will walk in beauty.

Even the action–walking–is a practice that lends itself to virtue. The prayer hopes for the prayer-sayer to be surrounded in beauty. But it’s not just that! One’s words will be beautiful! Because of this, the prayer hopes to bring, at the very least, the virtue of being able to speak beautifully!

I think this prayer and lifeway fits solidly within virtue ethics.

Philosophy and Academia Aren’t the Most Important Things in the World

Back when I was in graduate school, I took it upon myself to be very snobby. I thought what I was doing–aspiring to be a professional philosopher–was the most important thing on Earth.

Well, I was wrong.

All philosophers need food and, these days, I respect the job of a fruit-picker more than that of an academic.

I’m going into business and while I don’t mean to trump anybody, that means, with lots of hope and work, I’ll be putting something good into existence. That’s what business people do.

As an undergrad, I thought studying business was for weak minds who solely care about money.

Now I see that it’s actually an opportunity to understand how people operate, to understand how the world works and, with a little luck, put something into existence–a business–that could make the world a better place.

Currently, business people have to interact with all kinds of people. You get the highest selection of the population in business. Yet, while this is happening, academia isolates itself from non-academics.

That’s really too bad.

I don’t regret going to school, but there are things about myself I regret. And when a former philosophy professor tried telling me they think there’s other important jobs beyond philosophy, I didn’t believe her.

I have changed and now see that it quenches my intellect and more to be in business. What an opportunity I have been given!

No More “Cheesy Feels”

I know you probably mean well when you go on LinkedIn and offer cheesy feels. But cheesy feels don’t keep me warm at night. Even if you’re not Christian, you can learn a thing or two from the book Boundaries.

Some folks appear to think that having a high EQ and good soft skills means offering cheap cheesy feels. That’s not so.

Having these skills means knowing when to say no and what to tolerate. It means not only offering your employees a nice place to work but keeping them safe from predators and toxic people.

I just made a comment on Twitter, in fact, stating that personal psychological problems are so often played out in industry. We can have democratic, equitable and fair workplaces in the form of workplace democracy. Why don’t we?

I postulate that it’s because we’ve been taught and personally take on the idea of power and control as Founders. The desire to have power and control is a psychological problem that I can’t fix for you. There’s a difference between assertive and aggressive. I say a bountiful business starts with assertive people who don’t simply offer cheesy feels for likes, follows and influence. A bountiful business begins with people who know when to say yes and when to say no.

Don’t let your problems play out on the field. Cheesy feels are too often enabling of bad behavior that harms people and the bottom line. Know when to offer support and when to simply walk away.

That’ll help keep me warm at night.

“I’m Qualified, Bitch!”

I have, in various capacities, hired and fired people. Trust me, it’s tougher to fire people than you expect. But this isn’t about firing people. This is about the hiring process. If you didn’t get the job, I hope this helps you understand why.

It starts with qualifications, yes. Being qualified for a job is important.

But it really goes beyond that.

I don’t think people should beg for jobs, but being kind and polite is a good start.

There’s a trend I have found as a female hiring manager that is troubling, though, and it may be the reason you didn’t get the job: sexism.

As a hiring manager, I have gotten berated and brow-beaten by (mostly male) job seekers. It’s really as though they think, “Bitch, give me the job.”

I’m here to tell you that’s not going to work.

We are in a new era and part of that era is having excellent research on how outstanding teams operate. It’s known, for example, that diverse and equitable teams perform better than old, male-centered, stratified teams.

That means your sexism counts against you.

To add, we know that creating flourishing work cultures means taming the toxicity. Adding toxic people to the team means the work culture will do poorly.

There’s much more than the mere “being qualified” that goes into selecting who to hire. Some call it having good “soft skills” or a “a good EQ.” Either way, bringing a sexist team member on is a liability. I’m not going to have my other employees treated badly by you.

In the end, sexism is a losing frame of mind all around. It’s bad for you, bad for work cultures and bad for business.

Do I Really Hate Trump?

That’s a question I was asked. Apparently, when you live in a world of hate, it’s easy to imagine others being full of hate.

Do I hate Trump?

No.

If you’ve been following along, you know I will encourage you to not vote for him. There’s plenty of other viable candidates to choose from.

But don’t confuse this with hatred.

I’ll tell you a story: I had a bad relationship once. When it ended, I told the person to never contact me again. They had been abusive and are somehow broken beyond repair. It’s not up to me to diagnose them. That’s for some therapist to do. All I know is that I’m finished with that person.

It’s with that kind of longevity, that kind of fortitude and self-respect, that I write with now regarding Trump. I think of him, in a way, as an abusive lover to The People. And The People should break up.

I want nothing to do with him. So much so that I’d like to move on, select who I’m going to vote for, and simply make beauty in the world.

There is no hatred from me. There is, in fact, no feelings for him. Nothing.

If you think people like me are full of hatred, think again. We are the ones making things blossom in the world. The creators. The inventors. The thinkers. There’s not much room for hatred (or being around toxicity) when you’re busy making the world a better place.

Remember that.

Groove with the Moon

But all the good graffiti got painted over in time
She watched the last faceless chain replace the last five and dime
And she wondered if the only noble thing
Ain’t to just to get a big garden and plant it in the spring

Kiss the city goodbye in some big graceful gesture
And focus on the moon’s groove, groove with the moon
Focus on the moon’s groove and groove with the moon
Focus on the moon’s groove, groove with the moon

Emancipate Minor, Ani Difranco

I’m still in planning stages of my business. It’s good to take a while in planning.

There’s a trend I’ve been following by Ritika Puri–with my own little twists.

I can’t say I know Puri’s mind, but she has a fresh take on things and she begun to stay away from toxic people and cultures.

This, I think, is good.

As business people, we have the ability to make the world the way it should be. We can create welcoming spaces and caring, empathetic cultures.

I have found when I’m not focused on the “bottom line,” I’m not only less stressed, I’m more productive and more creative.

There’s a terrible causticity in the air, if you breathe it. I have shut out most of the toxicity from my life and have found I am better able to accomplish things I want in life, including balance and happiness.

A business can be equitable and fair.

I know.

That may be a bold statement.

But it’s true. Business has a bad rap, but it doesn’t have to be that way.

One way I’m making my business equitable is by giving it a democratic structure. You can do this with a corporation, I’ve read, but most don’t. People tend to be power-hungry and controlling. They want to be the one in charge: The all-powerful CEO.

But you can organize your business so that employees and members have a say and a vote. Many big corporations call their employees “Team Members,” but don’t give them a say at board meetings.

I’m attempting to end the lip service.

When you shut out the negative voices and stop listening to caustic narratives, you can begin to create a more beautiful, just world.

In Which I May Be a Conspiracy Theorist

I have decided I won’t really be telling people who to vote for. Instead, I’ve made it my life’s ambition to tell you who not to vote for in 2020. That person is Donald J. Trump.

You may (or may not) know the current reasons most offer. My reason goes beyond this–and I truly hope I’d feel the same way were I not diagnosed with a psychological disability.

See, Trump has proposed putting people with mental illness in institutions. He specifically said he’s for re-opening institutions.

In addition to my known philosophy background, I do indeed have psychology background, too. I have worked as a Mental Health Case Manager for a short time. There’s reasons we have this kind of outpatient care these days. And the reasons can be quite terrifying.

No, no. It’s not simply because people with mental illnesses have been treated horribly in institutions, though that’s true, too.

The most frightening part, to my mind, is that people who had nothing in particular “wrong” with them were institutionalized. Do you know about Cointelpro? Do you want to see something like that happening again?

The situation is ripe for such a thing.

Beyond my own self-caring and selfish reasons for not voting for Donald J. Trump is my real, more powerful motive: I don’t want this happening to you.

If you are the 1 in 5 people with a mental illness, if you know someone with a mental illness, if you are a plain old rabble-rouser, if you tend to question things, join me in not voting for Donald J. Trump in 2020.

Our freedom may depend on it.

Philosopher-Entrepreneurs

Back when I was in graduate school, I learned about Donald Brownstein. He’s a billionaire hedge fund manager who happened to study philosophy. At the time, I was pretty comfortable in a middle class neighborhood. I was also pretty content. Still, I looked around at bright fellow philosophy students and thought about what good they may be able to do with a billion dollars.

Fast forward 10 years.

I now have a business idea.

I’ve had several business ideas in the past, but this one is different. It may actually come to fruition.

I’m still in the planning stages, but things are looking good.

So, how does one become a philosopher-entrepreneur? Let me tell you, although you may have to acquire some skills, it’s probably easier than writing an original thesis!

  1. The Idea. For starters, you don’t need an original idea. I know. This may dumbfound you. But, really, if you live in an area where there’s few restaurants, you don’t need to come up with the next novel idea. You just need a solid plan for a restaurant.
  2. The Plan. Which brings me to the next phase of the business: The Almighty Business Plan. You can look online at how to create one. While they may seem frivolous and unnecessary, they actually help you solidify your idea into moving, working parts. This, I’ve found, is incredibly helpful. Beyond being helpful, they come in handy when you are pitching your idea to investors and banks!

With these two things–The Idea and The Plan–you can move onto making your business concrete. And that’s exactly where I am at the moment with my current business idea.

You’ll want to keep your idea under wraps at first, but you will also want to run it by trusted sources to get feedback. Keeping your idea under wraps prevents someone else from jumping the gun before you and seizing the market.

Philosophy students, they say, tend to be good entrepreneurs. There’s laws and regulations you have to abide by (which is fine by me), but typically you have freedom (say, in casual dress codes) as a business owner that may suit philosophers. To boot, there’s always a challenge if you’re a start up–something philosophers seem to enjoy!

I hope this has helped anyone would may wish to go into business for themselves. I may never be Don Brownstein, but pursuing a passion project has its own benefits.

Skills to Pay the Bills: Philosophers on the Non Academic Job Market

Kevin J.S. Zollman‘s post on non academic careers got me thinking. It’s been about 10 years since I had to (gradually, and with a fight) leave academia due to illness. Over the years, I have experienced a lot. And this experience may be able to assist those coming after me. It was just the other day, in fact, that I offered my CV-turned-resume to someone on Twitter to look over because they wanted to know how to convert a CV into a resume for non academic jobs.

I stayed in arrested development as a perpetual student for a long time, but I have begun to strike out and have now matured and become much more comfortable with myself and my “voice.” I can’t rush these things for you if you haven’t reached them yet, but it’s a place where I feel I can do some good in assisting people coming after me in philosophy. So here’s some advice for you.

The work you do in school really does count on the non academic job market. Right now, I see jobs daily for things like Social Media Coordinator. If you contributed to a philosophy blog in school, even if it’s a student blog, like I was on, it counts that you know how to manage WordPress, work Twitter, and form a page on Facebook.

In fact, there are many skills you pick up along the way that are transferable. For example, I worked on the book Reading Bernard Williams when I was in graduate school. This did not merely give me the ability to talk about Williams, though. I edited papers. This gave me editing experience! Paid editing experience!

I used this experience to go on to edit a memoir, work as an Research Assistant for a book on AI and automation and do various other editing and writing gigs.

When you’re on the job market, you need to think about all the things you did in school because each extracurricular, each lowly-stipend assistant-ship, probably gave you skills that are valuable on the non academic job market.

Typically, they tell you in philosophy that studying philosophy will give you excellent and monetarily valuable critical thinking skills. And it’s true! While I have never seen a job announcement specifically ask for critical thinking skills, this is something hiring managers look for in an interview for many jobs.

You do, indeed, have skills. Many, many skills. If you choose to (or, as in my case, have to) work outside academia, remember this.